Do You Need to Send a Demand Letter?
Whether a demand letter is legally required depends on your state and the type of claim. In most cases, demand letters are strongly recommended but not mandatory.
When Demand Letters Are Required:
- Some state laws require demand letters before suing for specific claims (e.g., security deposits, consumer protection, warranty claims)
- Contracts often require written notice before legal action
- Some small claims courts require evidence of attempted resolution
When Demand Letters Are Optional But Recommended:
- Most general civil claims
- Personal debts
- Service disputes
- Most contractor disputes
States With Notable Requirements
California
- Security deposit claims: Landlords must itemize deductions within 21 days; tenants should send demand before suing
- Consumer warranty claims: Under the Song-Beverly Act, demand may trigger additional damages
- Contractor disputes: Notice to contractor may be required under Right to Repair Act
Texas
- Deceptive Trade Practices: Written demand 60 days before filing suit required to recover attorney's fees
- Landlord-tenant: Specific notice requirements for security deposit claims
Florida
- Civil remedies: Pre-suit notice required for many consumer protection claims
- Landlord-tenant: Seven-day notice required before termination
New York
- General: No specific demand letter requirement for most claims
- Consumer protection: Written notice recommended before AG complaint
Massachusetts
- Consumer protection (Ch. 93A): Written demand required 30 days before filing suit
- Security deposits: Triple damages available if landlord doesn't respond to proper demand
Michigan
- Security deposits: Landlord must respond within 30 days of tenant's request
- Consumer protection: Certain claims require pre-suit notice
Pennsylvania
- Unfair trade practices: Written notice 30 days before filing recommended
- Landlord-tenant: Specific notice requirements vary by claim type
Illinois
- Consumer fraud: Demand letter recommended before filing
- Security deposits: Specific notice requirements exist
Note: Laws change. Always verify current requirements with local legal resources.
What Your State Law Means for You
If Demand Letter Is Required:
Make sure your letter meets all statutory requirements:
- Send within required timeframes
- Include all required information
- Use the right delivery method
- Give the required response period
Failure to comply may bar your lawsuit or limit your recovery.
If Demand Letter Is Recommended:
- Send one anyway—it's rarely a disadvantage
- Courts view it favorably
- It may resolve your dispute without litigation
- It creates documentation of your claim
Check Your Contract:
Even if state law doesn't require it, your contract might. Many contracts include notice provisions requiring written demand before legal action.
Security Deposit Rules by State
Security deposit disputes are common, and many states have specific rules:
| State | Return Deadline | Demand Required? | Damages Available |
|---|---|---|---|
| CA | 21 days | Recommended | Up to 2x deposit |
| TX | 30 days | Recommended | 3x deposit + $100 |
| FL | 15-60 days | Required | Deposit + damages |
| NY | 14 days | Recommended | Deposit + interest |
| MA | 30 days | Required | 3x deposit |
| IL | 30-45 days | Required | 2x deposit |
| PA | 30 days | Required | 2x deposit |
Timelines are simplified; actual rules vary based on circumstances.
Finding Your State's Specific Rules
Resources to Check:
- State Attorney General Website
- State Bar Association
- Local Legal Aid
- Court Self-Help Centers
- Your Contract
When in Doubt:
Send a demand letter. Even when not required, it rarely hurts your case and often helps.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I skip the required demand letter?
If your state requires a demand letter for your type of claim and you don't send one, your lawsuit may be dismissed or you may not be able to recover certain damages (like attorney's fees or punitive damages). Courts may also give you a chance to send the demand and refile.
How do I find out if my state requires a demand letter?
Check your state's consumer protection website, contact your state Attorney General's office, consult with a local attorney, or research your specific type of claim. Requirements vary by claim type, not just by state.
Can I sue the same day I send my demand letter?
Generally no, if a demand letter is required. You typically must wait for the response period to pass (often 14-30 days). Even when not required, filing immediately looks unreasonable to judges and may hurt your case.
Ready to Create Your Demand Letter?
Use our free AI-powered generator to create a professional demand letter in minutes. Includes state-specific legal citations.
Generate Your Demand Letter Now