Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. For advice specific to your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your area.
Insurance companies profit by collecting premiums and denying claims. When your legitimate claim is denied or underpaid, you have legal rights to fight back. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) provides consumer resources and complaint filing options. Understanding the appeals process and bad faith laws can make the difference between getting nothing and getting everything you're owed.
Bad Faith Damages: If an insurer unreasonably denies or delays your claim, you may be entitled to more than just the policy amount - including emotional distress, punitive damages, and attorney fees in many states.
Common Reasons for Denial
Legitimate Denials
- Exclusion clearly applies
- Policy lapsed for non-payment
- Claim outside coverage period
- Deductible not met
- Coverage limits exhausted
Questionable Denials
- Vague policy language interpreted against you
- Pre-existing condition claims (health)
- Technicalities in filing
- Undervaluation of damages
- Unexplained delays
Bad Faith Denials
- Ignoring evidence supporting claim
- Unreasonable interpretation of policy
- Failure to investigate properly
- Delaying without explanation
- Lowballing to force settlement
Get the Denial in Writing: Always request a written denial with specific policy language cited. Verbal denials are harder to appeal and challenge.
Understanding Your Policy
Key Policy Sections
- Declarations: Coverage amounts, deductibles
- Insuring agreement: What's covered
- Exclusions: What's not covered
- Conditions: Your obligations
- Definitions: How terms are interpreted
Interpretation Rules
- Ambiguous language interpreted in your favor
- Exclusions must be clear and specific
- Reasonable expectations of insured matter
- Insurance contracts are adhesion contracts
Common Coverage Types
- Property: Home, auto, personal
- Health: Medical expenses
- Life: Death benefits
- Disability: Income replacement
- Liability: Third-party claims
The Appeals Process
Internal Appeal
- Request complete claim file
- Review denial letter carefully
- Identify basis for denial
- Gather supporting documentation
- Submit written appeal within deadline
What to Include in Appeal
- Specific policy provisions supporting claim
- Facts contradicting denial
- Additional evidence (photos, estimates, reports)
- Expert opinions if applicable
- Case law if helpful
Appeal Deadlines
- Health insurance: Often 180 days
- Property/casualty: Varies by state/policy
- Check policy for specific timeframes
- State law may provide additional time
Request Your File: You have the right to see everything the insurer has about your claim. Request the complete claim file - it often reveals weaknesses in their denial.
External Review and Complaints
State Insurance Commissioner
- File complaint online or by mail
- Commissioner investigates complaints
- Can force insurer to review denial
- Creates official record
External Review (Health Insurance)
- ACA requires external review option
- Independent third party reviews
- Decision is binding on insurer
- Usually free to consumer
When to Hire Attorney
- Significant claim amount
- Complex policy issues
- Bad faith suspected
- Appeals unsuccessful
- Disability or life insurance denials
Bad Faith Insurance Practices
What Constitutes Bad Faith
- Unreasonable denial of valid claim
- Failure to conduct adequate investigation
- Misrepresenting policy terms
- Unreasonable delays in processing
- Failure to communicate
- Lowball settlement offers
Damages Available
- Full policy benefits
- Consequential damages
- Emotional distress damages
- Punitive damages (in some states)
- Attorney fees and costs
Proving Bad Faith
- Document all communications
- Keep timeline of delays
- Save all correspondence
- Note unreturned calls
- Get expert opinions
Statute of Limitations: Bad faith claims have time limits. Don't wait too long to consult an attorney if you suspect bad faith - deadlines vary by state.
Specific Insurance Types
Property Insurance
- Get independent damage estimates
- Document all damage with photos
- Challenge depreciation calculations
- Request public adjuster if needed
Health Insurance
- Appeal all denials (high success rate)
- Request peer-to-peer review
- Use external review process
- Cite medical necessity
Auto Insurance
- Get multiple repair estimates
- Challenge total loss valuations
- Demand OEM parts if policy allows
- Don't accept first diminished value offer
Disability Insurance
- Provide thorough medical documentation
- Get attending physician support
- Document functional limitations
- Consider ERISA implications
Taking Legal Action
When to Sue
- Appeals exhausted
- Significant money at stake
- Clear policy violation
- Bad faith evident
Types of Claims
- Breach of contract
- Bad faith (tort)
- State consumer protection violations
- ERISA claims (employer plans)
Finding an Attorney
- Insurance bad faith specialists
- Many work on contingency
- Check state bar referral
- Review attorney's track record
Fight Your Insurance Denial
Generate a demand letter for insurance claim disputes and appeals.
Create Your Letter