Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. For advice specific to your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your area.
If you lost your case, an appeal might give you another chance - but appeals are not retrials. The U.S. Courts system explains how appellate courts review whether lower courts made legal errors. Understanding this process is essential before deciding whether to appeal.
Strict Deadlines: Appeal deadlines are typically 30 days from judgment and are strictly enforced. Miss the deadline and you lose your right to appeal forever.
What Is an Appeal?
An appeal asks a higher court to review whether the lower court made legal errors:
- Review of legal rulings, not factual disputes
- No new evidence or witnesses
- Based on trial court record
- Argued through written briefs
- Sometimes oral argument
Grounds for Appeal
What Can Be Appealed
- Legal errors: Court applied wrong law
- Procedural errors: Rules violated
- Evidentiary rulings: Evidence wrongly admitted/excluded
- Jury instructions: Wrong instructions given
- Insufficient evidence: No reasonable basis for verdict
What Cannot Be Appealed
- Disagreement with factual findings
- Jury believed other side's witnesses
- Judge's discretionary decisions (usually)
- Issues not raised at trial
- New evidence you found later
Preservation: You generally can't raise issues on appeal unless you objected at trial. If you didn't say "objection" when evidence was admitted, you may have waived that argument.
Types of Appeals
Small Claims Appeals
- Often "trial de novo" - complete new trial
- Appeal to superior court
- Short deadline (often 30 days)
- Relatively informal
Civil Appeals
- Appeal to Court of Appeals
- Based on trial record only
- Written briefs required
- More formal and complex
Supreme Court Appeals
- Discretionary (court chooses cases)
- Important legal questions only
- Very rarely granted
The Appeals Process
Step 1: Notice of Appeal
- File within deadline (usually 30 days)
- Simple form identifying judgment
- Pay filing fee
- Serve on other parties
Step 2: Record on Appeal
- Court reporter prepares transcript
- Clerk prepares clerk's transcript
- All exhibits assembled
- Can be very expensive
Step 3: Briefing
- Opening brief: Appellant argues errors
- Responding brief: Appellee defends judgment
- Reply brief: Appellant responds
- Strict page limits and deadlines
Step 4: Oral Argument
- Not always granted
- Brief presentation to judges
- Judges ask questions
- Usually 10-30 minutes per side
Step 5: Decision
- Written opinion issued
- Can take months to years
- Affirm, reverse, or remand
Appeal Costs: Appeals are expensive - transcript costs ($3-$10 per page), filing fees ($500-$1,000+), and attorney fees if represented. Budget carefully before appealing.
Standards of Review
De Novo
Appellate court decides fresh:
- Questions of law
- No deference to trial court
- Best chance for reversal
Abuse of Discretion
Very deferential:
- Discretionary rulings
- Evidentiary decisions
- Reversed only if unreasonable
Substantial Evidence
Factual findings:
- Was there evidence to support finding?
- Not whether appellate court agrees
- Hardest to overturn
Writing an Appellate Brief
Key Components
- Statement of issues: Exact legal questions
- Statement of facts: From the record
- Argument: Legal analysis with citations
- Conclusion: Specific relief requested
Effective Briefing Tips
- Cite to record (transcript page numbers)
- Focus on strongest arguments
- Address counter-arguments
- Follow all formatting rules exactly
- Meet all deadlines
Appeal Outcomes
Possible Results
- Affirmed: Lower court upheld
- Reversed: Lower court overturned
- Remanded: Sent back for more proceedings
- Modified: Judgment changed
After the Decision
- May be able to petition for rehearing
- May appeal to higher court
- If reversed, case returns to trial court
Should You Appeal?
Consider These Factors
- Was there a legal error (not just unfair result)?
- Did you preserve the issue at trial?
- What standard of review applies?
- Cost vs. potential recovery
- Time involved (1-3 years typical)
- Can you collect even if you win?
Appeal Success Rates
- Most appeals are affirmed
- Reversal rates vary by issue
- Legal errors reversed more often
- Factual findings rarely reversed
Reality Check: Appeals courts affirm most decisions. Only appeal if you have a genuine legal error, not just because you disagree with the result.
Stay of Judgment
Stopping Enforcement
- Appeal doesn't automatically stop judgment
- May need to post bond
- Bond equals judgment amount plus interest
- Protects winner if appeal fails
Pro Se Appeals
Self-Represented Challenges
- Complex procedures
- Strict formatting requirements
- Legal research required
- Held to same standards as attorneys
- Consider consulting attorney for brief review
Better to Resolve Early
Appeals are expensive and uncertain. Resolve disputes before court if possible.
Create Your Letter